Last updated Nov 3, 2026
A newborn has multiple fractures noted at birth, including healing rib fractures suggesting prenatal injury. The baby has blue sclerae. Family history reveals the father has had multiple fractures and hearing loss.
Most AD; COL1A1 or COL1A2 (α1 and α2 chains of type I collagen); null alleles lower the amount of normal collagen, structural variants act as dominant negatives
- Type I (mild): null allele, reduced collagen quantity
- Types II-IV: structural variants, abnormal collagen quality
- Rare AR forms: collagen processing genes (CRTAP, P3H1 (formerly LEPRE1), PPIB)
Types:
| Type | Severity | Sclerae | Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | Mild | Blue | Fractures decrease after puberty, hearing loss |
| II | Lethal perinatal | Blue | Multiple fractures, crumpled bones |
| III | Severe | Variable | Progressive deformity, short stature |
| IV | Moderate | Normal/gray | Variable fractures, dental involvement |
COL1A1 and COL1A2 encode the α1 and α2 chains of type I collagen, a heterotrimer of two α1 chains and one α2 chain, abundant in bone, dermis, tendon, and cornea. Glycine, the smallest amino acid, must occupy every third position for the chains to fold into a triple helix, which forms from the C-terminal end toward the N-terminal end.
- Quantitative (type I, loss of function): nonsense, frameshift, and splice variants halve COL1A1 mRNA. Less structurally normal collagen means less bone and brittle bones.
- Qualitative (types II to IV, dominant negative): glycine substitutions, small in-frame deletions or duplications, and exon skipping make an abnormal chain that is built into the triple helix and the fibril. Helix folding is delayed, overmodified trimers are retained, less collagen is secreted, and abnormal collagen in the matrix compromises bone integrity.
That is why a null allele is milder than a structural variant. Among structural variants, a large residue replacing glycine in the C-terminal 70% of the α1 helix is almost always lethal, and variants nearer the N-terminal end are milder. Somatic or gonadal mosaicism is found in up to 16% of families. The recessive CRTAP, P3H1, and PPIB forms fall outside this mechanism.
- Fractures with minimal trauma
- Blue sclerae (type I collagen in sclera)
- Dentinogenesis imperfecta (types III, IV)
- Hearing loss (progressive, type I)
- Short stature (types II-IV)
- Wormian bones on skull X-ray
- Clinical and radiographic: recurrent low-trauma fractures, low bone density, Wormian bones, bowing deformities
- Confirmatory molecular testing of COL1A1 and COL1A2 (AR forms involve collagen-processing genes)
- Distinguishing from non-accidental trauma is critical when fractures present in infancy
- Severe forms (type II) often detected on prenatal ultrasound (multiple fractures, short/bowed long bones, decreased skull mineralization)
- Bisphosphonates, orthopedic management, physical therapy
The classic features of OI: Fragile Bone, Blue Sclerae, Hyperextensibility, Presenile Deafness.
This diagram illustrates the difference between quantitative (COL1A1 null allele, producing less but normal collagen in type I OI) and qualitative (structural variant producing abnormal collagen in types II-IV) defects in type I collagen.
